The Real Reason the Schmidts Went to West Bend, Iowa

The Schmidts of West Bend, Iowa will dominate the record-breaking 2016 Schmidt Reunion in Spencer, Iowa. Yet, of all the places that the Schmidt immigrants from Machtlos, Germany could have settled in, why did they choose West Bend, Iowa?

Hessian MercenariesHessian Troops in British Pay in the US War of Independence, by C. Ziegler, 1799 (Wikimedia commons)

The first residents of Machtlos, Germany to come to the New World were several young men who were recruited as Hessian mercenaries to fight for the British in the American Revolutionary War. Of the six known Machtlos mercenaries, three died of non-battle causes (such as disease, accident, etc.). The other three deserted to the Americans, and then disappeared into the New World, probably earning farmland as a reward for their desertion, and most likely changing their names to avoid retribution. One of those Machtlos mercenaries who died in America was a member of the Schmidt family–Johann Heinrich Metz (died September 1777), who was a great grandson of Hans Heinrich Schmidt.

It would not be until 65 years later, in 1842, when the next known Schmidt from Machtlos would come to America: Johannes Schmidt (b. 5 Oct 1822, son of Johannes Schmidt and Eva Christina Günther), who took the ship Marianne from Bremen to Baltimore on July 20th of that year.

New York City and the East River 1848New York City and the East River, by Eliphalet M. Brown, 1848 (Wikimedia commons)

Four years later, a young lady from Machtlos named Martha Elisabeth Lindemann (b. 6 May 1820, daughter of Dietrich Lindemann and Anna Cunigunde Schuchardt) arrived in New York aboard the ship Meta on 24 June 1846. She made her way out to Saint Louis, Missouri, which had recently become the epicenter for immigrant settlement. Saint Louis was romanticized by immigrants as a pleasant, uncrowded city full of wide open space and opportunity. Because of the well-developed German community there, it was nicknamed “the American Rhineland”. Saint Louis was soon to boast the highest percentage of foreign-born residents of any city in America.

Saint Louis in mid 1800s

Saint Louis, Missouri in the mid 1800s (Source: Missouri State Historical Society)

There in Saint Louis, on 29 June 1847, Martha Elisabeth Lindemann married John Adam Starff (b. 27 Jan 1813 in Niederkirchen bei Deidesheim, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany), who drove a horse-drawn bus (probably shuttling travelers from the ferry landing to the city). They would go on to have 5 children: Daniel, Matilda, Thomas, and 2 who died in infancy. While residing in Saint Louis, John was recruited as a soldier in the Mexican-American War, where he served for a year. The experience was a harsh one, as American soldiers suffered severe shortages of clothing, food, and medicine during the Mexican-American War. Statistically, this war ranks as the deadliest in American history, with the highest mortality rate for soldiers. After the war, John desired a simpler and more peaceful life, so he took his family up the Mississippi River and settled in Rochester, Iowa.

Battle of Churubusco 1847Battle of Churubusco, by J. Cameron, 1847 (Wikimedia commons)

After one year in Rochester, John used his military bounty land warrant, which he received for serving a full year in the United States army, and in August of 1849 acquired 160 acres of land in Taylor Township, Benton County, Iowa. He subsequently traded 72 acres of that land for a horse. John Adam and Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Starff were the very first German immigrants ever to settle in Benton County, Iowa. He was known for his sense of humor about the fact that he was the only German-speaker in the area, and would say, “I speak German, French, and Swedish. If you can get hold of my horses’ bridle-reins, just you try and make them go” (because the horses would not understand commands spoken in English). The city of Vinton, Iowa was founded in Benton County in that same year of 1849. John built his own wooden wagon, and then he would cut and cart three loads of wood into Vinton every day.

Emigrants Coming to IowaEmigrants Coming to Iowa,
from the book “History of Iowa from the Earliest Times to the Beginning of the Twentieth Century” (Wikimedia commons)

In the decade after Martha Elisabeth Lindemann immigrated from Machtlos, Germany to America, there were many more residents of Machtlos who made the journey to the United States, but they all settled in Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, or Washington DC.

On May 8th, 1858, Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Starff’s niece, Maria Elisabeth (Lindemann) Hotzel and her husband Adam Hotzel, immigrated to America and settled in Lee County, Illinois, where members of the Kersten family of Machtlos had already started settling as early as 1854. Then, on January 3rd, 1863, Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Starff’s younger brother, Michael Lindemann (with his wife and two daughters), came and joined the Hotzels in Lee County, Illinois. Hearing good reports about Iowa, both the Hotzel family and the Michael Lindemann family went and joined the Starff family in Benton County, Iowa in 1865. Another niece of Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Starff’s, named Maria Elisabeth Lindemann, came from Machtlos with her widowed father, Johannes “John” Lindemann (brother of Martha Elisabeth [Lindemann] Starff), immigrating in the late 1860s. Maria and her father Johannes settled in the Vinton area and Maria married a John Rommann. Thus, the Benton/Tama Counties area became a gathering point for immigrant families from Machtlos, Germany.

SS SilesiaSS Silesia
(Source: Ancestry.com. Passenger Ships and Images [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2007.)

On June 6th, 1881 aboard the steam ship Silesia, the 17-year-old shoemaker Georg Karl Schmidt of Machtlos immigrated to America with many of his neighbors (who were largely from the Schneider family). From the New York harbor, they took a train to Ellsworth County, Kansas. Two years later, in 1883, Karl’s uncle and aunt, Conrad Jacob Schmidt and Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Schmidt, along with their children and some other family members, also made the journey to America.

Karl Schmidt and Maggie Lindemann marriage certificateKarl Schmidt (“Chas Smith”) and Maggie Lindemann marriage certificate,
9 December 1887, Taylor Township, Benton County, Iowa

Conrad Jacob Schmidt and Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Schmidt decided to settle in the Dysart/Vinton area to live close to Martha’s father, Johannes “John” Lindemann, her sister, Maria Elisabeth (Lindemann) Rommann, her cousin, Maria Elisabeth (Lindemann) Hotzel, and her aunt, Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Starff. Along with the Conrad and Martha Schmidt family came Karl’s brother, Wilhelm Conrad Schmidt, as well as some young cousins, Mike Lindemann and Anna Margaretha “Maggie” Lindemann (brother and sister). Karl Schmidt decided to move from Ellsworth County, Kansas up to Dysart, Iowa to be near his brother, uncle, and other extended family. Maggie Lindemann then married Karl Schmidt, and Mike Lindemann married Lizzie Schmidt (daughter of Conrad and Martha Schmidt, and a first cousin to Karl Schmidt).

Coal Miners at Work 1887Coal Miners at Work, 1887
(Source: Tennessee Secretary of State Website)

The Schmidt family largely engaged in farming in the Dysart/Vinton area. Karl Schmidt and his cousin Henry Schmidt (son of Conrad and Martha Schmidt) also did occasional work in the coal mines up in the northwest part of Iowa near Fort Dodge. With Karl and Henry Schmidt bringing back good reports about the farm land in northwest Iowa, Mike and Lizzie (Schmidt) Lindemann were induced to move in that direction, settling in 1888 on a farm in Humboldt County, Iowa, about 20-30 miles northwest of Fort Dodge.

Herman Louis SchmidtHerman Balthasar Louis Schmidt, barber in West Bend, Iowa
(Photo courtesy of Linda Swalin)

That same year, Lizzie (Schmidt) Lindemann’s brother, Herman Schmidt, moved from Dysart up to northwest Iowa to be nearer to his sister and brother-in-law. Herman took up the barber trade in the town of West Bend, Iowa, about 20-30 miles northwest of Humboldt.

Conrad and Martha Lindemann SchmidtConrad Jacob Schmidt and Martha Elisabeth (Lindemann) Schmidt
(Photo courtesy of Linda Swalin)

Herman and Lizzie’s parents (Conrad and Martha) and siblings (Henry, Anna and Margaret) soon followed them up to northwest Iowa, settling in about 1890 on farmland in the area that spanned from Kossuth County (just east of West Bend) down to neighboring Humboldt County.

Karl and Maggie SchmidtGeorg Karl Schmidt and Anna Margaretha “Maggie” (Lindemann) Schmidt

Finally, in 1893, Karl and Maggie (Lindemann) Schmidt moved their family from Tama County, Iowa up to the West Bend area. They settled on farmland in Palo Alto County, just west of the town of West Bend.

These Schmidt families who settled around the area of West Bend, Iowa multiplied into the thousands. Now, they are joining with thousands of other descendants of the Machtlos Schmidt family from across the country for a record-breaking reunion at the Clay County Fairgrounds in Spencer on July 30-31, 2016. Be there and represent your branch of this great clan!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *